View Issue Details
|ID||Category||Date Submitted||Last Update|
|0008470||bugs||2020-11-16 20:54||2020-12-06 19:30|
|Fixed in Version|
|Summary||0008470: Source list contains duplicates when audio is dragged into the editor versus using the import dialog|
|Description||See discussion here: https://discourse.ardour.org/t/expected-source-list-behavior/104961|
Summary pretty much says it all.
|Steps To Reproduce||Drag audio into Ardour and duplicate sources appear in the source list. Using import dialog doesn't exhibit this behavior.|
|Tags||No tags attached.|
this happens when dragging a sound onto an existing track,
it does not happen when dragging into an empty space (which creates a new track)
having just bought Mixbus I see the problem is exactly the same there (I guess this is not a surprise)
...then I tried again on Mixbus just to check I hadn't been dreaming and it didn't show double copies,
but then I clicked to view Regions, back to Source lists and hey presto - doubles are there after all
(couldn't get this to happen in Ardour, or to happen again in Mixbus)
||seems to be fixed in Ardour 6.4 for me (OS X 10.15.7)|
The bad news is: I have no explanation why it was an issue, nor why it's now gone.
Looking at the changelog, I don't see an explicit fix for this between 6.3 and 6.4.
Maybe it only happens sometimes, or only for some files...
||Still happens on 6.4 here (Win). When I switch over to Linux I'll test there too. However, I can confirm AliMacD's finding that it doesn't add duplicates when you drag a file into empty space.|
I did a few more tests all starting with new, empty sessions (using the same folder of sounds I used for testing above in 6.3 and 6.4) and all was fine. No duplicates.
Then I opened an existing session and the problem returned immediately.
And now even with clean sessions I get doubles.
related - I'd like to be able to drop files into the Source List instead of directly onto the timeline (though I'd be happy for both to co-exist). Drag & drop is really useful when bringing together audio from a number of different disks & folders into a new project.
...I wonder if fixing this might uncover the solution for the problem above.
||Also occurs when dragging directly from the source list (6.5/Linux).|
|2020-11-16 20:54||bachstudies||New Issue|
|2020-11-21 12:32||AliMacD||Note Added: 0025244|
|2020-11-21 12:52||AliMacD||Note Added: 0025245|
|2020-11-22 16:18||AliMacD||Note Added: 0025254|
|2020-11-22 16:41||x42||Note Added: 0025255|
|2020-11-22 17:21||bachstudies||Note Added: 0025256|
|2020-11-22 17:41||AliMacD||Note Added: 0025257|
|2020-11-25 09:41||AliMacD||Note Added: 0025266|
|2020-12-06 19:30||thekoala2||Note Added: 0025289|