View Issue Details
|ID||Category||Date Submitted||Last Update|
|0007900||bugs||2020-02-13 19:22||2020-04-19 20:18|
|Platform||Some Other Linux||OS||Some Other Linux||OS Version||unknown|
|Fixed in Version|
|Summary||0007900: Deleting .mid files from session directory tree causes segfault on next load|
|Description||Deleting .mid files from session directory tree causes segfault on next load|
|Steps To Reproduce||in the session root of an ardour session with a midi track, delete *.mid from the directory tree.|
Try to load session in ardour.
|Additional Information||Ardour6.0.pre0.3409 (built using 6.0-pre0-3409-gd7fed7c52e and GCC version 9.2.1 20191008)|
|Tags||No tags attached.|
What do you expect in this case?
Should Ardour create empty MIDI regions in place (like silent audio-regions are created for missing audio)?
For missing Audio files, Ardour shows a dialog and asks the user to locate the files. Audio is non-destructive and Ardour can reference external-files (which may be moved).
MIDI however is always in Ardour's session-folder, since it's edited destructively no external files can be referenced. If a file is missing, there's almost no point in asking the user about it.
I think the way forward is to re-create the missing files as empty .mid, and retain the regions. Then show an error dialog (not just a log message):
"MIDI files were found missing: ... Ardour has replaced them file empty/silent MIDI data. If this is unexpected and you have backup files, you can manually copy them over, and re-start Ardour"
||You can use your best judgement on that. For my use case, I'd be ok with no regions, empty regions or even deleted tracks (but this seems extreme). All I care about is that the session is loadable (and loadable without having to click an "ok" through an error message), even when expected .mid files are gone.|
||There will have to be an OK at some point. We're never going to sanction "oh, just ignore all missing files today, tomorrow and forever".|
||Yeah I get that. I'm mostly concerned about the lua version.|
||Fixed in 6.0-pre0-3417-g60a2406056 -- the warning (Missing Source Files) is shown in the GUI only. Headless/Lua will silently replace the MIDI with silence|
Issue has been closed automatically, by Trigger Close Plugin.
Feel free to re-open with additional information if you think the issue is not resolved.
|2020-02-13 19:22||mantis_n1oif||New Issue|
|2020-02-15 18:35||x42||Note Added: 0020962|
|2020-02-15 18:41||mantis_n1oif||Note Added: 0020963|
|2020-02-16 18:51||paul||Note Added: 0020964|
|2020-02-17 00:02||mantis_n1oif||Note Added: 0020965|
|2020-02-18 00:31||x42||Note Added: 0020966|
|2020-02-19 14:32||x42||Assigned To||=> x42|
|2020-02-19 14:32||x42||Status||new => resolved|
|2020-02-19 14:32||x42||Resolution||open => fixed|
|2020-04-19 20:18||system||Note Added: 0023811|
|2020-04-19 20:18||system||Status||resolved => closed|