View Issue Details
| ID | Project | Category | View Status | Date Submitted | Last Update |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0005489 | ardour | bugs | public | 2013-05-16 18:38 | 2013-06-06 12:41 |
| Reporter | djbarney | Assigned To | |||
| Priority | normal | Severity | major | Reproducibility | always |
| Status | feedback | Resolution | open | ||
| Summary | 0005489: Fast operation of MIDI control leads to failiure of associated Ardour3 mixer fader control | ||||
| Description | Operating a MIDI control at fast speed leads to loss of sync of the associated fader in both main window and mix window. The Ardour3 fader tracks the MIDI control at low speeds but above a certain speed of operation loses sync with the control. Further slow operation of the MIDI control picks up the fader sync again. Midi Tracer window shows that Ardour3 is receiving the MIDI messages OK. The included output of Midi Tracer shows one complete slow up and down operation of the MIDI control (on an M-Audio Oxygen 49 keyboard) followed by a few very fast up and down operations. | ||||
| Additional Information | revision 3.1-75-gcadfc2a | ||||
| Tags | 3.1, Midi | ||||
|
2013-05-16 18:38
|
mid_tracer.txt (9,200 bytes)
19:02:49.490287 Controller chn 15 1 97 19:02:49.564953 Controller chn 15 1 95 19:02:49.644951 Controller chn 15 1 92 19:02:49.700956 Controller chn 15 1 90 19:02:49.759621 Controller chn 15 1 88 19:02:49.818292 Controller chn 15 1 86 19:02:49.914285 Controller chn 15 1 83 19:02:49.980956 Controller chn 15 1 80 19:02:50.039632 Controller chn 15 1 78 19:02:50.116950 Controller chn 15 1 75 19:02:50.164948 Controller chn 15 1 73 19:02:50.234273 Controller chn 15 1 71 19:02:50.282273 Controller chn 15 1 68 19:02:50.348979 Controller chn 15 1 66 19:02:50.404946 Controller chn 15 1 64 19:02:50.466278 Controller chn 15 1 61 19:02:50.522302 Controller chn 15 1 59 19:02:50.580935 Controller chn 15 1 57 19:02:50.628926 Controller chn 15 1 53 19:02:50.676910 Controller chn 15 1 51 19:02:50.746262 Controller chn 15 1 49 19:02:50.804922 Controller chn 15 1 46 19:02:50.882267 Controller chn 15 1 44 19:02:50.938266 Controller chn 15 1 41 19:02:50.996919 Controller chn 15 1 38 19:02:51.055588 Controller chn 15 1 35 19:02:51.111582 Controller chn 15 1 33 19:02:51.170248 Controller chn 15 1 30 19:02:51.218240 Controller chn 15 1 26 19:02:51.287590 Controller chn 15 1 24 19:02:51.335579 Controller chn 15 1 21 19:02:51.394242 Controller chn 15 1 18 19:02:51.460907 Controller chn 15 1 16 19:02:51.516911 Controller chn 15 1 13 19:02:51.586244 Controller chn 15 1 11 19:02:51.644903 Controller chn 15 1 8 19:02:51.700902 Controller chn 15 1 6 19:02:51.770240 Controller chn 15 1 3 19:02:51.858249 Controller chn 15 1 0 19:02:53.063548 Controller chn 15 1 1 19:02:53.122219 Controller chn 15 1 3 19:02:53.178217 Controller chn 15 1 6 19:02:53.226210 Controller chn 15 1 9 19:02:53.303550 Controller chn 15 1 11 19:02:53.391555 Controller chn 15 1 13 19:02:53.450214 Controller chn 15 1 16 19:02:53.508880 Controller chn 15 1 18 19:02:53.554216 Controller chn 15 1 20 19:02:53.604885 Controller chn 15 1 23 19:02:53.671555 Controller chn 15 1 25 19:02:53.738208 Controller chn 15 1 27 19:02:53.778241 Controller chn 15 1 31 19:02:53.834218 Controller chn 15 1 34 19:02:53.884885 Controller chn 15 1 37 19:02:53.940894 Controller chn 15 1 40 19:02:53.988883 Controller chn 15 1 44 19:02:54.047556 Controller chn 15 1 46 19:02:54.095552 Controller chn 15 1 49 19:02:54.154214 Controller chn 15 1 51 19:02:54.220880 Controller chn 15 1 54 19:02:54.271549 Controller chn 15 1 57 19:02:54.338213 Controller chn 15 1 59 19:02:54.434206 Controller chn 15 1 62 19:02:54.492875 Controller chn 15 1 64 19:02:54.559548 Controller chn 15 1 66 19:02:54.618204 Controller chn 15 1 68 19:02:54.666210 Controller chn 15 1 71 19:02:54.732869 Controller chn 15 1 73 19:02:54.802202 Controller chn 15 1 76 19:02:54.868877 Controller chn 15 1 78 19:02:54.946206 Controller chn 15 1 80 19:02:55.012869 Controller chn 15 1 83 19:02:55.082198 Controller chn 15 1 85 19:02:55.148864 Controller chn 15 1 88 19:02:55.196859 Controller chn 15 1 90 19:02:55.255529 Controller chn 15 1 93 19:02:55.306190 Controller chn 15 1 95 19:02:55.362191 Controller chn 15 1 97 19:02:55.428858 Controller chn 15 1 101 19:02:55.498193 Controller chn 15 1 103 19:02:55.546192 Controller chn 15 1 106 19:02:55.612856 Controller chn 15 1 108 19:02:55.671540 Controller chn 15 1 110 19:02:55.738195 Controller chn 15 1 114 19:02:55.788859 Controller chn 15 1 116 19:02:55.855527 Controller chn 15 1 119 19:02:55.914185 Controller chn 15 1 121 19:02:55.970188 Controller chn 15 1 123 19:02:56.058182 Controller chn 15 1 125 19:02:56.135528 Controller chn 15 1 127 19:02:58.927425 Controller chn 15 1 108 19:02:58.935402 Controller chn 15 1 95 19:02:58.946080 Controller chn 15 1 80 19:02:58.954077 Controller chn 15 1 68 19:02:58.964742 Controller chn 15 1 57 19:02:58.972740 Controller chn 15 1 50 19:02:58.983404 Controller chn 15 1 47 19:02:59.002080 Controller chn 15 1 37 19:02:59.012739 Controller chn 15 1 27 19:02:59.023410 Controller chn 15 1 17 19:02:59.031407 Controller chn 15 1 6 19:02:59.042069 Controller chn 15 1 0 19:03:00.519399 Controller chn 15 1 9 19:03:00.527391 Controller chn 15 1 16 19:03:00.538050 Controller chn 15 1 24 19:03:00.548713 Controller chn 15 1 33 19:03:00.556713 Controller chn 15 1 43 19:03:00.567382 Controller chn 15 1 51 19:03:00.578047 Controller chn 15 1 60 19:03:00.586047 Controller chn 15 1 70 19:03:00.596713 Controller chn 15 1 78 19:03:00.604713 Controller chn 15 1 87 19:03:00.615382 Controller chn 15 1 95 19:03:00.626050 Controller chn 15 1 102 19:03:00.634047 Controller chn 15 1 110 19:03:00.644715 Controller chn 15 1 119 19:03:00.655405 Controller chn 15 1 127 19:03:02.500698 Controller chn 15 1 114 19:03:02.508693 Controller chn 15 1 106 19:03:02.516689 Controller chn 15 1 97 19:03:02.527377 Controller chn 15 1 87 19:03:02.538024 Controller chn 15 1 75 19:03:02.546020 Controller chn 15 1 62 19:03:02.556685 Controller chn 15 1 49 19:03:02.564684 Controller chn 15 1 36 19:03:02.575352 Controller chn 15 1 22 19:03:02.586015 Controller chn 15 1 10 19:03:02.594016 Controller chn 15 1 0 19:03:02.788689 Controller chn 15 1 20 19:03:02.799350 Controller chn 15 1 36 19:03:02.807350 Controller chn 15 1 54 19:03:02.818011 Controller chn 15 1 73 19:03:02.828698 Controller chn 15 1 89 19:03:02.836680 Controller chn 15 1 106 19:03:02.847348 Controller chn 15 1 120 19:03:02.858046 Controller chn 15 1 127 19:03:03.068687 Controller chn 15 1 109 19:03:03.079345 Controller chn 15 1 96 19:03:03.087343 Controller chn 15 1 81 19:03:03.098007 Controller chn 15 1 67 19:03:03.108678 Controller chn 15 1 52 19:03:03.116677 Controller chn 15 1 37 19:03:03.127352 Controller chn 15 1 24 19:03:03.138022 Controller chn 15 1 6 19:03:03.146013 Controller chn 15 1 0 19:03:03.340684 Controller chn 15 1 16 19:03:03.348673 Controller chn 15 1 31 19:03:03.359336 Controller chn 15 1 49 19:03:03.370000 Controller chn 15 1 69 19:03:03.378000 Controller chn 15 1 89 19:03:03.388666 Controller chn 15 1 106 19:03:03.396668 Controller chn 15 1 121 19:03:03.410030 Controller chn 15 1 127 19:03:03.602008 Controller chn 15 1 110 19:03:03.609999 Controller chn 15 1 98 19:03:03.620666 Controller chn 15 1 84 19:03:03.628665 Controller chn 15 1 68 19:03:03.639334 Controller chn 15 1 52 19:03:03.649997 Controller chn 15 1 36 19:03:03.657996 Controller chn 15 1 23 19:03:03.668662 Controller chn 15 1 8 19:03:03.679332 Controller chn 15 1 0 19:03:03.863336 Controller chn 15 1 21 19:03:03.871329 Controller chn 15 1 36 19:03:03.882000 Controller chn 15 1 53 19:03:03.889999 Controller chn 15 1 73 19:03:03.900662 Controller chn 15 1 91 19:03:03.911332 Controller chn 15 1 109 19:03:03.919329 Controller chn 15 1 125 19:03:03.930029 Controller chn 15 1 127 19:03:04.116662 Controller chn 15 7 124 19:03:04.132661 Controller chn 15 1 109 19:03:04.143326 Controller chn 15 1 98 19:03:04.151324 Controller chn 15 1 85 19:03:04.161992 Controller chn 15 1 72 19:03:04.172660 Controller chn 15 1 57 19:03:04.183325 Controller chn 15 1 42 19:03:04.191324 Controller chn 15 1 27 19:03:04.201990 Controller chn 15 1 16 19:03:04.209988 Controller chn 15 1 5 19:03:04.220656 Controller chn 15 1 0 19:03:04.404658 Controller chn 15 1 16 19:03:04.412657 Controller chn 15 1 29 19:03:04.423322 Controller chn 15 1 45 19:03:04.433983 Controller chn 15 1 62 19:03:04.441989 Controller chn 15 1 78 19:03:04.452656 Controller chn 15 1 96 19:03:04.463320 Controller chn 15 1 111 19:03:04.474010 Controller chn 15 1 126 19:03:04.482023 Controller chn 15 1 127 19:03:04.684659 Controller chn 15 1 114 19:03:04.695319 Controller chn 15 1 102 19:03:04.703317 Controller chn 15 1 90 19:03:04.713982 Controller chn 15 1 76 19:03:04.721982 Controller chn 15 1 61 19:03:04.732651 Controller chn 15 1 46 19:03:04.743319 Controller chn 15 1 31 19:03:04.753981 Controller chn 15 1 16 19:03:04.761982 Controller chn 15 1 2 19:03:04.772647 Controller chn 15 1 0 |
|
|
There is a "threshold" control in the Generic MIDI GUI to alter how Ardour handles this. I know that the default is not OK on my Peavey PC1600x but does work with a Behringer BCF device. There is no single setting that will work for all devices - try playing with the threshold and report back .... |
|
|
Ah, no one told me about that :) I'll check this later, thanks. |
|
|
Yes, that was it. Currently set to 73 and even the fastest operations are synced. I wonder if there should be a button named "options" next to the control surface name ? The text below it is very easy to miss. |
|
|
hello! i ran across the same issue and i would suggest this is "fixed" in another way... right now it feels like a bug, all though it seems it's not! the concept of "threshold" on the generic MIDI is a little vague. perhaps by calling this function something like "smoothness" or "response" would make it more self explanatory. also, moving the whole control surface section to a new tab in the preferences might make it easier to discover. or at least put it on the "MIDI" tab as it would seem more logical than under "user interaction". thanks |
|
|
your suggestions are implemented in git. thanks for the prod. |
| Date Modified | Username | Field | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2013-05-16 18:38 | djbarney | New Issue | |
| 2013-05-16 18:38 | djbarney | File Added: mid_tracer.txt | |
| 2013-05-16 18:39 | djbarney | Tag Attached: 3.1 | |
| 2013-05-16 18:39 | djbarney | Tag Attached: Midi | |
| 2013-05-16 18:49 | paul | Note Added: 0014914 | |
| 2013-05-16 18:49 | paul | Status | new => feedback |
| 2013-05-16 21:06 | djbarney | Note Added: 0014925 | |
| 2013-05-17 13:50 | djbarney | Note Added: 0014927 | |
| 2013-06-06 10:36 | jesperdahlback | Note Added: 0014955 | |
| 2013-06-06 12:41 | paul | Note Added: 0014956 |
