View Issue Details

IDCategoryLast Update
0002825features2010-10-29 16:18
ReporteroofusAssigned Tocth103 
ReproducibilityN/A 
Status closedResolutionfixed 
PlatformDell D830 core2duo T9300 2.5GHzOSMandrivaOS Version2009.1
Product VersionSVN/2.0-ongoing 
Fixed in Version 
Summary0002825: Option, when normalising, to specify what is used as the peak reference when multiple regions are selected.
DescriptionOption, when normalising, to specify what is used as the peak reference when multiple regions are selected.

When multiple regions are selected for normalising two options should be available. 1) Normalise each region independently. 2) Use the highest peak of all the regions as the reference.
TagsNo tags attached.

Activities

nettings

2009-08-14 09:31

manager   ~0006526

is it at all possible to normalize multiple regions in ardour 2.0-ongoing? if so, how? (it would be great if it were.)

if multiple regions are being normalized, the default should always be relative normalization (i.e. to the highest peak in any of the selected regions), so that the relative levels aren't changed.

oofus

2009-08-14 09:47

developer   ~0006527

Well, I had just assumed that selecting multiple regions would give a normalise option in the context menu. I was wrong. So, a bug report required first, 'normalise option is missing from the context menu when multiple regions are selected'. I have a feeling it used to be there, but maybe I'm wrong.

Agree that the default should be relative normalisation.

seablade

2009-08-14 19:16

manager   ~0006528

Yes it is possible to normalize multiple regions at once, I have done it multiple times. I think I either went through the top menu, or used the shortcut to do it.

      Seablade

oofus

2010-08-29 19:36

developer   ~0008945

Both of these issues have now been addressed in 3.x. When multiple regions are selected the right click context menu now contains a normalise option. The resulting dialogue now has an option for normalising across all regions, however I think the wording is unclear, it doesn't convey what the option setting will do. Suggest the wording and control be changed to two radio buttons with labels : "Normalise regions individually" and "Normalise regions relatively", or something very similar.

oofus

2010-10-25 23:00

developer   ~0009304

Text still not changed so current text still confusing me ! Also suggest adding a progress bar. I just normalised a selection of large regions and it took 30 seconds +. Wasn't sure if the job was being done or Ardour had frozen.

cth103

2010-10-26 00:31

administrator   ~0009307

Should all be fixed in SVN.

oofus

2010-10-26 00:43

developer   ~0009308

Last edited: 2010-10-26 11:39

Getting better. Progress bar doesn't seem to work. ie the progress bar doesn't progress during normalising. It sometimes shows some progress but not until all the normalising has been done. Also normalising using the highest peak across the selected regions doesn't seem to work. The regions end up slightly louder but not to the level that they would be if they were done individually, taking into account the average level of those regions. Normalising all the selected regions individually does work.

oofus

2010-10-29 01:50

developer   ~0009312

All issues fixed, and a few more addressed.

oofus

2010-10-29 16:18

developer   ~0009322

see notes

Issue History

Date Modified Username Field Change
2009-08-13 10:38 oofus New Issue
2009-08-14 09:31 nettings Note Added: 0006526
2009-08-14 09:47 oofus Note Added: 0006527
2009-08-14 19:16 seablade Note Added: 0006528
2009-08-14 19:38 seablade Status new => acknowledged
2010-07-22 12:59 oofus cost => 0.00
2010-07-22 12:59 oofus Target Version => 3.X
2010-08-29 19:36 oofus Note Added: 0008945
2010-10-25 23:00 oofus Note Added: 0009304
2010-10-26 00:31 cth103 Note Added: 0009307
2010-10-26 00:31 cth103 Status acknowledged => resolved
2010-10-26 00:31 cth103 Resolution open => fixed
2010-10-26 00:31 cth103 Assigned To => cth103
2010-10-26 00:43 oofus Note Added: 0009308
2010-10-26 00:43 oofus Status resolved => feedback
2010-10-26 00:43 oofus Resolution fixed => reopened
2010-10-26 11:39 oofus Note Edited: 0009308
2010-10-29 01:50 oofus Note Added: 0009312
2010-10-29 01:50 oofus Status feedback => resolved
2010-10-29 01:50 oofus Resolution reopened => fixed
2010-10-29 16:18 oofus Note Added: 0009322
2010-10-29 16:18 oofus Status resolved => closed