View Issue Details

IDProjectCategoryView StatusLast Update
0010160ardourbugspublic2026-02-20 20:39
Reporterdspasic Assigned Topaul  
PrioritynormalSeverityminorReproducibilityalways
Status assignedResolutionopen 
PlatformApple MacintoshOSMacOSOS Version10.12 or later
Product Version9.0 
Summary0010160: Velocity of midi notes recorded prior to first bar in cue recording is wrong
DescriptionHi, when you hold notes while cue page rec is counting in (4,3,2,1) and those notes are recorded on the first beat > velocity is lower than played
Steps To Reproduce1. new project
2. create midi track
3. start recording new midi clip in cue page
4. play and hold chord/notes when counting-in (4,3,2,1)
5. recorded velocity on first beat is wrong (all other note recordings are fine)
TagsNo tags attached.

Activities

dspasic

2026-02-06 20:59

reporter   ~0029839

check velocity of first notes recorded https://youtu.be/-DVZ-rWMhbU
all notes are played with fixed velocity (qwerty and on-screen keyboard)

paul

2026-02-12 00:07

administrator   ~0029858

yeah, this is commented in the code already. We need to keep more information around from before the recording actually starts.

paul

2026-02-18 05:46

administrator   ~0029897

should be fixed by commit 3e52656879

dspasic

2026-02-18 16:02

reporter   ~0029899

Hi Paul, please correct me if i'm wrong - i'm on rev 9.0-45-ga157a7e60f
and it looks like not fixed:
https://youtu.be/QDKTve_vfjQ
Thanks

paul

2026-02-18 16:33

administrator   ~0029900

I don't think that's new enough. You need 9.0-51 or later ...

dspasic

2026-02-18 16:36

reporter   ~0029901

i assumed. Thanks for confirmation. I'll wait for nightly build then.
Thanks again Paul, looking forward to it!

paul

2026-02-18 16:45

administrator   ~0029902

the nightlies are already available ...

dspasic

2026-02-18 17:01

reporter   ~0029903

latest for macos arm is: 9.0-45-ga157a7e60f
or i'm missing something

dspasic

2026-02-20 19:18

reporter   ~0029943

Still not fixed in:
Ardour 9.0.110 rev 9.0-110-g4e31f14a12

paul

2026-02-20 19:25

administrator   ~0029948

Can you describe what you do or do not see/hear?

dspasic

2026-02-20 19:31

reporter   ~0029949

Hi Paul,
The behavior is same like i already reported and demonstrated. Here is another quick demonstration with new version:
(less than 20 seconds) https://youtu.be/fEzmwQrH7Wc
the issue: recorded midi notes which are held before first measure velocity is way lower than it actually is.
Thanks

paul

2026-02-20 19:57

administrator   ~0029952

You're absolutely right! The fix I did was for our generalized MIDI state tracker, not for cue recording. Will fix that now.

paul

2026-02-20 20:00

administrator   ~0029953

Hmm, but that was in fact the right place to fix it ...

dspasic

2026-02-20 20:19

reporter   ~0029955

Hey Paul, no hard feelings i just wanted to write my observations in the new version.
I wish you a great weekend!

paul

2026-02-20 20:39

administrator   ~0029957

OK, I checked much more carefully this time, and I think it is really fixed now as of 9.0-118-g60d1a315bd

Issue History

Date Modified Username Field Change
2026-02-06 20:57 dspasic New Issue
2026-02-06 20:59 dspasic Note Added: 0029839
2026-02-12 00:07 paul Assigned To => paul
2026-02-12 00:07 paul Status new => acknowledged
2026-02-12 00:07 paul Note Added: 0029858
2026-02-18 05:46 paul Status acknowledged => feedback
2026-02-18 05:46 paul Note Added: 0029897
2026-02-18 16:02 dspasic Note Added: 0029899
2026-02-18 16:02 dspasic Status feedback => assigned
2026-02-18 16:33 paul Note Added: 0029900
2026-02-18 16:36 dspasic Note Added: 0029901
2026-02-18 16:45 paul Note Added: 0029902
2026-02-18 17:01 dspasic Note Added: 0029903
2026-02-18 17:01 dspasic File Added: Screenshot 2026-02-18 at 18.00.17.png
2026-02-18 17:01 dspasic File Added: Screenshot 2026-02-18 at 18.00.27.png
2026-02-20 19:18 dspasic Note Added: 0029943
2026-02-20 19:25 paul Note Added: 0029948
2026-02-20 19:31 dspasic Note Added: 0029949
2026-02-20 19:57 paul Note Added: 0029952
2026-02-20 20:00 paul Note Added: 0029953
2026-02-20 20:19 dspasic Note Added: 0029955
2026-02-20 20:39 paul Note Added: 0029957