MantisBT - ardour
View Issue Details
0002636ardourfeaturespublic2009-04-18 01:242014-01-03 02:38
hg87 
hg87 
normalfeatureN/A
resolvedfixed 
 
3.0 
0002636: MIDI editing/sequencer functionality in ardour
I know that work on that part is going on on ardour 3.0, and i really like to see that feature in it.
The recent versions of that 3.0 show that this will get really great, but until now there is no final release of that things in ardour.

I don't want to talk much on that topic, but i just wanted to start an "Bug Report" with detonations when this stuff is finished.

Hopefully this is a good idea, and doesn't bother anyone.

For my part i'll detonate 50$ when this stuff is finished.
3.0, Midi, Sequencer
Issue History
2009-04-18 01:24hg87New Issue
2009-04-18 01:35hg87Sponsorship Addedhg87: US$ 50
2009-04-18 01:35hg87Sponsorship Total0 => 50
2009-04-24 09:57PipeManMusicSponsorship AddedPipeManMusic: US$ 25
2009-04-24 09:57PipeManMusicSponsorship Total50 => 75
2009-04-25 04:03thorgalNote Added: 0005904
2009-04-27 08:12hg87Note Added: 0005908
2009-05-01 08:42meisterhSponsorship Addedmeisterh: US$ 25
2009-05-01 08:42meisterhSponsorship Total75 => 100
2009-05-04 11:04realhangmanSponsorship Addedrealhangman: US$ 50
2009-05-04 11:04realhangmanSponsorship Total100 => 150
2009-05-05 04:43hackmeisterSponsorship Addedhackmeister: US$ 20
2009-05-05 04:43hackmeisterSponsorship Total150 => 170
2009-05-07 13:04esperantoNote Added: 0005981
2009-05-07 13:04esperantoSponsorship Addedesperanto: US$ 50
2009-05-07 13:04esperantoSponsorship Total170 => 220
2009-05-09 03:07justynSponsorship Addedjustyn: US$ 25
2009-05-09 03:07justynSponsorship Total220 => 245
2009-05-09 03:41realhangmanSponsorship Updatedrealhangman: US$ 100
2009-05-09 03:41realhangmanSponsorship Total245 => 295
2009-05-09 03:48realhangmanNote Added: 0005984
2009-05-09 09:49LcutSponsorship AddedLcut: US$ 20
2009-05-09 09:49LcutSponsorship Total295 => 315
2009-05-13 06:50PipeManMusicNote Added: 0005992
2009-05-13 06:50PipeManMusicSponsorship UpdatedPipeManMusic: US$ 75
2009-05-13 06:50PipeManMusicSponsorship Total315 => 365
2009-05-13 06:51PipeManMusicSponsorship UpdatedPipeManMusic: US$ 100
2009-05-13 06:51PipeManMusicSponsorship Total365 => 390
2009-05-13 08:14hg87Note Added: 0005993
2009-05-13 08:15hg87Sponsorship Updatedhg87: US$ 100
2009-05-13 08:15hg87Sponsorship Total390 => 440
2009-05-15 06:15AxeTotaSponsorship AddedAxeTota: US$ 50
2009-05-15 06:15AxeTotaSponsorship Total440 => 490
2009-05-15 06:23hackmeisterSponsorship Updatedhackmeister: US$ 5
2009-05-15 06:23hackmeisterSponsorship Total490 => 475
2009-05-15 06:23hackmeisterSponsorship Updatedhackmeister: US$ 25
2009-05-15 06:23hackmeisterSponsorship Total475 => 495
2009-05-15 06:24hackmeisterNote Added: 0005996
2009-05-15 06:26hackmeisterNote Edited: 0005996
2009-05-15 06:26hackmeisterSponsorship Updatedhackmeister: US$ 50
2009-05-15 06:26hackmeisterSponsorship Total495 => 520
2009-05-15 06:27hackmeisterNote Edited: 0005996
2009-05-15 06:54JazzyPuppyNote Added: 0005997
2009-05-15 06:54JazzyPuppyNote Deleted: 0005997
2009-05-15 07:33JazzyPuppyNote Added: 0005998
2009-05-15 07:39hg87Note Added: 0005999
2009-05-15 07:39JazzyPuppySponsorship AddedJazzyPuppy: US$ 100
2009-05-15 07:39JazzyPuppySponsorship Total520 => 620
2009-05-15 07:41JazzyPuppyNote Edited: 0005998
2009-05-15 07:42JazzyPuppyNote Edited: 0005998
2009-05-15 08:46AxeTotaNote Added: 0006000
2009-05-15 08:47AxeTotaSponsorship UpdatedAxeTota: US$ 100
2009-05-15 08:47AxeTotaSponsorship Total620 => 670
2009-05-29 22:35leaphionSponsorship Addedleaphion: US$ 100
2009-05-29 22:35leaphionSponsorship Total670 => 770
2009-05-29 22:36leaphionNote Added: 0006036
2009-06-03 10:50Steve_DSponsorship AddedSteve_D: US$ 100
2009-06-03 10:50Steve_DSponsorship Total770 => 870
2009-07-21 13:14hg87Note Added: 0006451
2009-07-22 13:57KuranesSponsorship AddedKuranes: US$ 5
2009-07-22 13:57KuranesSponsorship Total870 => 875
2009-07-23 11:57seabladecost => 0.00
2009-07-23 11:57seabladeTarget Version => 3.0
2009-07-23 11:57seabladecost0.00 =>
2009-07-23 18:14KuranesNote Added: 0006465
2009-07-23 18:16KuranesNote Edited: 0006465
2009-07-23 18:17KuranesNote Edited: 0006465
2009-07-25 15:11drobillaNote Added: 0006469
2009-07-25 15:12drobillaNote Edited: 0006469
2009-07-26 04:01hg87Sponsorship Updatedhg87: US$ 25
2009-07-26 04:01hg87Sponsorship Total875 => 800
2009-07-26 04:01hg87Sponsorship Updatedhg87: US$ 125
2009-07-26 04:01hg87Sponsorship Total800 => 900
2009-07-30 11:28aklausniSponsorship Addedaklausni: US$ 5
2009-07-30 11:28aklausniSponsorship Total900 => 905
2009-07-30 11:33aklausniNote Added: 0006475
2009-09-05 14:07qharleySponsorship Addedqharley: US$ 10
2009-09-05 14:07qharleySponsorship Total905 => 915
2009-09-17 01:39poameSponsorship Addedpoame: US$ 85
2009-09-17 01:39poameSponsorship Total915 => 1000
2009-11-10 07:31nickstuSponsorship Addednickstu: US$ 10
2009-11-10 07:31nickstuSponsorship Total1000 => 1010
2009-11-10 10:08tronhammerNote Added: 0007098
2009-11-10 10:09tronhammerNote Edited: 0007098
2009-12-06 06:14leethargoSponsorship Addedleethargo: US$ 90
2009-12-06 06:14leethargoSponsorship Total1010 => 1100
2009-12-21 01:08rekadoSponsorship Addedrekado: US$ 50
2009-12-21 01:08rekadoSponsorship Total1100 => 1150
2009-12-21 01:10rekadoNote Added: 0007250
2010-01-17 03:48bardeNote Added: 0007322
2010-02-14 03:59hg87Sponsorship Updatedhg87: US$ 25
2010-02-14 03:59hg87Sponsorship Total1150 => 1050
2010-02-14 04:00hg87Sponsorship Updatedhg87: US$ 150
2010-02-14 04:00hg87Sponsorship Total1050 => 1175
2010-03-20 12:08fsoNote Added: 0007413
2010-03-20 12:10fsoNote Edited: 0007413
2010-04-10 02:03hg87Tag Attached: 3.0
2010-04-10 02:03hg87Tag Attached: Midi
2010-04-10 02:03hg87Tag Attached: Sequencer
2010-04-10 02:05hg87Note Added: 0007475
2010-04-24 03:36cth103Target Version3.0 => 3.0-beta1
2010-04-24 12:48kosiiniSponsorship Addedkosiini: US$ 10
2010-04-24 12:48kosiiniSponsorship Total1175 => 1185
2010-04-28 07:29bsodSponsorship Addedbsod: US$ 5
2010-04-28 07:29bsodSponsorship Total1185 => 1190
2010-05-02 10:00Pfeffa-rahNote Added: 0007768
2010-05-14 10:47ChauncellorSponsorship AddedChauncellor: US$ 15
2010-05-14 10:47ChauncellorSponsorship Total1190 => 1205
2010-05-25 09:09lelangirNote Added: 0008033
2010-05-25 09:30lelangirSponsorship Addedlelangir: US$ 40
2010-05-25 09:30lelangirSponsorship Total1205 => 1245
2010-06-04 06:24bsodNote Added: 0008152
2010-06-30 04:27cth103Target Version3.0-beta1 => 3.0
2010-07-13 22:56triuneSponsorship Addedtriune: US$ 10
2010-07-13 22:56triuneSponsorship Total1245 => 1255
2010-07-13 22:57triuneNote Added: 0008428
2010-07-26 17:08realhangmanSponsorship Deletedrealhangman: US$ 100
2010-07-26 17:08realhangmanSponsorship Total1255 => 1155
2010-07-26 17:21realhangmanNote Added: 0008658
2010-07-26 18:53rekadoNote Added: 0008662
2010-07-26 21:26ChauncellorNote Added: 0008664
2010-07-26 21:47qharleyNote Added: 0008665
2010-07-27 05:54ChauncellorSponsorship UpdatedChauncellor: US$ 25
2010-07-27 05:54ChauncellorSponsorship Total1155 => 1165
2010-07-27 05:55ChauncellorSponsorship UpdatedChauncellor: US$ 40
2010-07-27 05:55ChauncellorSponsorship Total1165 => 1180
2010-07-28 10:14hg87Sponsorship Updatedhg87: US$ 100
2010-07-28 10:14hg87Sponsorship Total1180 => 1130
2010-07-28 10:18hg87Note Added: 0008677
2010-08-06 13:30DLC11Sponsorship AddedDLC11: US$ 15
2010-08-06 13:30DLC11Sponsorship Total1130 => 1145
2010-08-18 15:23Dave ENote Added: 0008859
2011-02-14 13:14nouanSponsorship Addednouan: US$ 15
2011-02-14 13:14nouanSponsorship Total1145 => 1160
2011-02-21 08:46thechanklyboreSponsorship Addedthechanklybore: US$ 50
2011-02-21 08:46thechanklyboreSponsorship Total1160 => 1210
2011-04-14 13:59realhangmanNote Added: 0010553
2011-04-19 07:19hg87Note Added: 0010595
2011-05-10 01:05JmGVSponsorship AddedJmGV: US$ 5
2011-05-10 01:05JmGVSponsorship Total1210 => 1215
2011-05-31 08:27hg87Sponsorship Updatedhg87: US$ 250
2011-05-31 08:27hg87Sponsorship Total1215 => 1365
2012-04-20 09:18badmuthahubbardSponsorship Addedbadmuthahubbard: US$ 10
2012-04-20 09:18badmuthahubbardSponsorship Total1365 => 1375
2013-01-05 07:52Cool GamesSponsorship AddedCool Games: US$ 5
2013-01-05 07:52Cool GamesSponsorship Total1375 => 1380
2013-03-21 10:28hg87Note Added: 0014766
2013-03-22 00:12esperantoNote Added: 0014767
2013-03-26 16:51justynNote Added: 0014781
2013-03-28 12:44leethargoNote Added: 0014785
2014-01-03 02:17naught101Note Added: 0015531
2014-01-03 02:31hg87Note Added: 0015532
2014-01-03 02:36hg87Note Added: 0015534
2014-01-03 02:36hg87Statusnew => resolved
2014-01-03 02:36hg87Resolutionopen => fixed
2014-01-03 02:36hg87Assigned To => hg87

Notes
(0005904)
thorgal   
2009-04-25 04:03   
do you mean "donate" or "detonate" ? :lol:
(0005908)
hg87   
2009-04-27 08:12   
@thorgal:
I meant "donate" and not "detonate", it seems that this typo was "saved" as correct in my brain, but for sure it doesn't make sense to detonate something. ;)

Nice to see that someone joined the "sponsoring" for 3.0.
(0005981)
esperanto   
2009-05-07 13:04   
using ubuntu repos...
(0005984)
realhangman   
2009-05-09 03:48   
Hey, just updated to 100 bucks as a response to Paul's posting ;)

What about getting 100 people sponsoring 100 bucks? This would just mean that we say that we will "buy" the 3.0 version for 100 bucks when it's released, which is pretty cheap I think!

Regards,
realhangman
(0005992)
PipeManMusic   
2009-05-13 06:50   
Alright, I'll up the my ante to $100. Anyone else with me?
(0005993)
hg87   
2009-05-13 08:14   
@PipeManMusic:
Yes, I'm on your side! -> 100$
(0005996)
hackmeister   
2009-05-15 06:24   
(edited on: 2009-05-15 06:27)
Upped by $30 now going to promise a total of $50. Lets show that this model can work.

(0005998)
JazzyPuppy   
2009-05-15 07:33   
(edited on: 2009-05-15 07:42)
[SOLVED] Used IE in a VirtualBox :-)
Thanks hg87 for the adblock thing!

Obviously I am too blind to see how to sponsor.
Could anyone help me out? Is there somewhere a link which says "sponsor this"?

Thank you!

(0005999)
hg87   
2009-05-15 07:39   
@JazzyPuppy:
Try to disable your adblock application, or add an execption for that frame.
(At my first try I had the same problem with it.)

Afterwards it's directly under the "bug description".
(0006000)
AxeTota   
2009-05-15 08:46   
I got another 50 on it. Hopefully I'm not broke by the time 3.0 is out.
(0006036)
leaphion   
2009-05-29 22:36   
Added 100$ as I'm interested in seeing this feature implemented.
(0006451)
hg87   
2009-07-21 13:14   
It seems that not that much people I expected are willing to donate for the MIDI features.

Also it looks for me like not many user have joined the feature support for MIDI since paul posted the article regarding the efforts which are necessary to implement this.
I understand what he does mean, but for my part, as a private user I'm not able to spend the amount of money which would be needed to cover the efforts which are behind the MIDI support.
And I think that the criticism was not really a incentive for getting this support thread what it was intended to. (To honor the efforts which was and is done to integrate MIDI into ardour, as community and not as single person.)

Maybe it would have been better to say: "Community thats really good and I do welcome this type of support, but try to imagine which efforts are behind that stuff. It would be good if you attach with what you think that it's worth and you're willing to give."
I really missed a statment of him which welcomes every amount of payment, as nobody of us claimed to cover (financially) all the amount of work which is needed to get it done.

So, come on all others out there which want/need to have MIDI in ardour and attach here with some of your bucks. (Or donate on the main page.)

Regards,
Harald
(0006465)
Kuranes   
2009-07-23 18:14   
(edited on: 2009-07-23 18:17)
I added $5. I have also been a $1/month subscriber one or two years ago for about a year.
I'm very interested in Ardour having MIDI capabilities.

Please, don't misunderstand that amount I donated and will donate.
I know $5 is really tiny, but I'm also very, very low on budget considering that I have to save as much as possible for loans, studies, etc. and where every single euro matters.

However it's very likely that this amount will increase (or even as an instant donation) as soon as I try out a [Mac OS X] build even with a minimum of MIDI recording/editing (or just editing -- the alpha releases planned for this summer?), and also as soon as I'm more stable financially.

As I understand it we're very far from that (MIDI editing in Ardour) to happen yet, but I'm hopeful, confident and would surely support the Ardour developers more if I could.

(0006469)
drobilla   
2009-07-25 15:11   
(edited on: 2009-07-25 15:12)
Every bit counts! Thanks everyone

... and we're not that far off at all ;)

(0006475)
aklausni   
2009-07-30 11:33   
I've added 5 USD and today i've donated 25 EUR for the complete project; for every track i finish with ardour i will spend 25 EUR again. I loved it. (o:

I am a programmer myself, but only familiar with "java". I know the hard work!

Regards, André
(0007098)
tronhammer   
2009-11-10 10:08   
(edited on: 2009-11-10 10:09)
I threw in $5 USD in sponsorship, and am hoping I can throw in more as time goes by

(0007250)
rekado   
2009-12-21 01:10   
I will donate $50 when MIDI is implemented. That would make Ardour perfect, especially considering that there are hardly any mature MIDI programs that make use of more than ALSA-MIDI.
Soon I'll donate for the project itself, once my PayPal account has been recharged.
(0007322)
barde   
2010-01-17 03:48   
I would spend 100$. maybe more when MIDI Support will be in.
(0007413)
fso   
2010-03-20 12:08   
(edited on: 2010-03-20 12:10)
i would also like to pay 99$ Dollar if MIDI is working. For me MIDI is so important. On Windows / Acid Pro 7 i tried 32 Tracks and scrolled mouse and clicked on menus, there was always getting something interupted (either the sound or graphics). On Ardour i could use 32 Stereo Tracks and scroll the mouse on the menu just like that with no interuption of anything. I have Dual XEON PC and RME DIGI 9652... I dont want to miss Ardour, but it needs to get MIDI

(0007475)
hg87   
2010-04-10 02:05   
It would be fine, if the people who announced that they will pay something when Midi support is in, could also attach to the sponsorship list.

Possibly you can't find the sponsorship frame if you have an adblocker running. Those apps tend to hide that sonsorship field.

Regards,
Harald
(0007768)
Pfeffa-rah   
2010-05-02 10:00   
Hi there,
I never used ardour BECAUSE it has no MIDI Sequencer.
Without that it's useless to me.

So, since I guess I am not verry special.....
I think there would be a bunch of new users when MIDI-sequencing is added.

I might want to donate, but at this stage I can't say for sure since I never tried Ardour because in its current state it's useless. (no insult intended...just useless for me personally.)

I'll keep an eye out for version 3.

greetz,
Pfeffa-rah
(0008033)
lelangir   
2010-05-25 09:09   
lack of MIDI-sequencing is what deters me from using Ardour. Not sure when 3.0 is coming out...but it'd solve all my problems!
(0008152)
bsod   
2010-06-04 06:24   
Although Ardour without midi is almost useless to me i've donated 10$. Will surely to pay more once midi support becomes available.

Dimitry
Odessa, Ukraine
(0008428)
triune   
2010-07-13 22:57   
gogogogogo! we need midi! get some alpha builds with a buildbot out on an launchpad apt repository! gogogogogo!
(0008658)
realhangman   
2010-07-26 17:21   
Hey folks,

I've just deleted my sponsorship of $100. Reason: I just paid it. Obviously, this doesn't mean that Ardour3 has been released, but rather that I paid my part beforehand. The financial situation looks bad, and I'd totally hate to get into the situation where there's no use for any donations any more (Paul qutting).

Have a look at Paul's comment here:
http://ardour.org/node/3715#comment-22114 [^]

I suggest that we all pay our sponsorships beforehand to get the money for this month together. I don't want to see A3 not being released; or the devs being pushed to release A3 overhasty just to create (necessary) income for the project instead of polishing A3 well.

Best regards
realhangman / Benjamin
(0008662)
rekado   
2010-07-26 18:53   
Thanks Benjamin for the news. I've paid my sponsorship of $50 just now. I wish that most people will follow. Paul quitting would tantamount to failure of the (loose-knit) community.
(0008664)
Chauncellor   
2010-07-26 21:26   
Paid. I'll leave my small amount on here an extra addition for when it's done (and it will be).
(0008665)
qharley   
2010-07-26 21:47   
I donated an extra $25 (leaving my small sponsorship for the actual time)

I'd love to see A3 released.
(0008677)
hg87   
2010-07-28 10:18   
Thanks for the notice!

I just donated 100$, and set my contribution for this features in here down to 100$.


Kind Regards,
Harald
(0008859)
Dave E   
2010-08-18 15:23   
I donated $20 and downloaded Ardour today, hoping to support the development of MIDI implementation. The program isn't very useful to me without it, so I've been "lurking" for some time, waiting to take the plunge when MIDI is available.

Best of luck! I eagerly await Ardour 3.0....
(0010553)
realhangman   
2011-04-14 13:59   
Hi everyone,

I've recognized that we are going the same path down again, unfortunately. I haven't heard anything from the devs yet, but last month's goal wasn't reached and now that we are in the middle of the month, we are not even at 30% of the goal. I'm a bit afraid that this will slow down development of A3 so I thought I'd pass by and share this with you.
Maybe some of you want to celebrate the alpha releases with some donations... I'm already a monthly donor and can't afford more atm.

Best
Benjamin
(0010595)
hg87   
2011-04-19 07:19   
@realhangman:
Thanks for the hint.

I just tried to help a bit.
This time I keep my reward for the MIDI support at the same level.

Dev's just don't get tired near the goal! :)
Looking forward to a beta/final version of A3.
A3 alpha is already really impressive and has a lot of cool features in there.


Best regards,
Harald
(0014766)
hg87   
2013-03-21 10:28   
I want to thank everyone who made this feature possible and consider this bug as fixed with the offical release of Ardour 3.


My donation of 250 USD was just sent.
Hopefully everyone else who had a bounty on this bug will donate as promised.


Many thanks to all contributors/developers, and please keep up this awesome work!


Best regards,
Harald Gutmann
(0014767)
esperanto   
2013-03-22 00:12   
just donated my $50

great job all!
(0014781)
justyn   
2013-03-26 16:51   
Paid, well done!
(0014785)
leethargo   
2013-03-28 12:44   
Paid!
(0015531)
naught101   
2014-01-03 02:17   
Should this bug be marked resolved or closed?
(0015532)
hg87   
2014-01-03 02:31   
@naught101:
From the technical view, I'd say this bug is resolved and can be closed.
On the other hand I'm not sure if all sponsors already made their donations.

Kind regards,
Harald
(0015534)
hg87   
2014-01-03 02:36   
Functionality added with the release of Ardour3.